Fascinating Philosophy
Fabulous Fiction
When I first encountered Diana Stangwell, in 1967, she was small and stocky, with a severe fringe, and reasonably talkative. As I remember, on that particular evening, she wore wire-framed spectacles, a black cashmere jersey, and brogues. In short, she was nothing like the kaftan-wearing, cotton-wool haired, ‘wrinkled, desiccated, shrunken’ (her words, not mine), uncommunicative old woman everyone recalls from the 2019 documentary. She didn’t chain smoke in those days, either.
We met at a party for ‘creative intellectuals’ in Hampstead, one of those salted peanuts & psychedelia affairs that were all the rage then, with the guest-list heavily weighted to the avant garde end of the spectrum. I’d already made a few films, mostly in the Andy Warhol mould – lingering shots of lampshades, with something fascinating just out of shot – and she’d just opened her first exhibition, on Portobello Road, which I’d visited a few days earlier. ‘Underattended’, was how she described it.
We became instant friends. I can’t remember whose idea it was to make a documentary about her exhibition, the day before it closed ‘for ever and ever’, but it turned out – a surprise to everyone – that she had a gift for talking intelligently and endearingly to the camera. As I’ve said before, in another life I really believe she could have been a TV presenter.
What was The Philosophy of Right, really? In a series of highly influential lectures on Hegel’s much earlier The Phenomenology of Spirit, delivered in Paris between 1933 and 1939, the Russian-born French philosopher Alexandre Kojève astonished his audience by claiming that Hegel was broadly right that history had ended at the beginning of the nineteenth century. Kojève’s assertion revolved around Hegel’s so-called Master-Slave (Herrschaft und Knechtschaft) Dialectic, a relatively short but pivotal story of an archetypal struggle-to-the-death between two people, one of whom ends up in subjection to the other. Yet Hegel tells us that it cannot end there. The contest was essentially fought for recognition, but the recognition the master gets from the slave is tainted because it is forced, and because the slave is considered inferior: the master’s domination is premised on a refusal to acknowledge the slave’s full humanity. In the end, the slave gets the better end of the deal, because his work allows him to reach a fuller self-consciousness.
Anyway, that film was the making of both of us, for different reasons. It took off in Paris, to begin with, then several weeks later, in New York, then, finally, in London.
